Morgan Hill Foods
Pacific Hill Manor
Nov. 20, 2008
   News Poll
 
If city or school district layoffs are coming, should pay cuts be considered
Layoffs
Paycuts
Past Polls
   Top Opinion
 
   Opinion
 

 Letters: Now is not the time to extend Santa Teresa Boulevard
Nov 18, 2008
 
 Questions linger, challenges ahead
Nov 18, 2008
 
  More Opinion...

OPINION > EDITORIALS


A small fix to VTA's structural nightmare
May 20, 2008
 By Morgan Hill Editorial Board

1. Band-aid fix is insufficient
There are real problems with the way that "small city" representation is handled on the Valley Transportation Agency's board of directors. 

The first problem is that VTA directors are not directly elected - the way that Santa Clara Valley Water District directors are - but instead are appointed by member agencies that include the city of San Jose, Santa Clara County, and several small cities in the VTA's service area.

The second problem is that small cities must share seats with other small cities. Cities are grouped together and votes are doled out according to population. 

Currently, South County's two small cities - Morgan Hill and Gilroy - share a seat with Milpitas. Group Four, as the cities are known, share one vote. The seat is rotated between the cities every two years, meaning that each city is without representation on the VTA board two out of every three years. Councilman Greg Sellers is currently the Group Four representative.



2. Real solutions require legislature's cooperation
Fixing either of those problems would require the approval of the state legislator and no one on the VTA board or staff is pressuring any of the South Bay's state legislators to carry such a  bill.  VTA officials did, however, lobby heavily for the state legislature to approve a bill that would allow the agency to pass 1/8-cent increment sales tax increases. Their effort, unfortunately, was successful.

But Morgan Hill City Councilman Greg Sellers convinced the VTA to adopt a change that addresses the length of time group board members hold their seats. With the change that takes effect in January, the VTA would "allow for and encourage" longer terms for group representatives. The argument in favor of this proposal is that it will allow directors to develop more expertise.



3. Downsides of longer terms are significant
While this idea has been lauded as an "easy" fix with "no downside," we disagree. We foresee lots of problems with longer times between each city's representation disenfranchising tens of thousands of voters. Just a quick look at the geography of Group Four through the BART prism shows the dissimilar interests forced upon this group. The BART-to-San Jose extension will directly benefit Milpitas, while it will not help and will likely ultimately harm South County.

We see very little upside with Sellers' proposal and huge downsides.

We acknowledge that reforming the VTA's board structure so board members are directly elected and so that small cities aren't disenfranchised two-thirds of the time is harder than Sellers' easy fix. But it is clearly the right thing to do. It's time the VTA got on with it.



Act now:
Contact the VTA Board of Directors to let them know your feelings on the issue. (408) 321-5680 or via e-mail: board.secretary@vta.org.


Morgan Hill Editorial Board
Got a question or a comment? Send us an email.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Although the Morgan Hill Times does not have any obligation to monitor this board, the Morgan Hill Times reserves the right at all times to check this board and to remove any information or materials that are unlawful, threatening, abusive, libelous, defamatory, obscene, vulgar, pornographic, profane, indecent or otherwise objectionable to the Morgan Hill Times in our sole discretion and to disclose any information necessary to satisfy the law, regulation, or government request. The Morgan Hill Times also reserves the right to permanently block any user who violates these terms and conditions. All threats to systems or site infrastructure shall be assumed genuine in nature and will be reported to the appropriate law enforcement authorities. Submission of any comments will be considered permission to use online or in print.

© Copyright 2008 MainStreet Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Any copying, redistribution or retransmission of any of the contents of this service without the express written consent of MainStreet Media, LLC. is expressly prohibited.

Add to Google Add to My Yahoo!  Email This Article  Print
Vietasia Restaurant
 Opinion: Editorials
Measure G's failure means it's time to become leaner and more efficient
Nov 18, 2008
 
Prostitution is not a victimless crime
Nov 11, 2008
 
Analyzing the historic vote
Nov 6, 2008
 
Now that's expensive city furniture
Oct 13, 2008
 
 Opinion: Letters to the Editor
Letters: Now is not the time to extend Santa Teresa Boulevard
Nov 18, 2008
 
Your Views
Nov 14, 2008
 
Letters to the editor: We'll miss Councilman Mark Grzan
Nov 6, 2008
 
Letters to the editor: Country needs to change direction
Nov 3, 2008
 
 Opinion: Guest Column
Just one election-day
Nov 11, 2008
 
Setting the record straight on Sen. Barack Obama's background
Oct 31, 2008
 
Recent crime trends: a report from the chief
Oct 30, 2008
 
Guest Column: Let Sarah Palin be Sarah Palin
Oct 2, 2008
 
More Editorials... More Letters to the Editor... More Guest Column...
 
Subscribe to FREE
breaking news updates
First Name: 
Last Name: 
Email: 


   
Quick Job Search
Enter Keyword(s):
Enter a City:  

Select a State:

Select a Category:


  - Advanced Job Search
  - Search by Category
 
Morgan Hill Recycling
 
 Obituaries

 Mildred J. Moniz
2/11/1918 - 11/16/2008

 Peter John Radulovich Sr.
7/2/1939 - 11/9/2008

 Robert Lopez Sotelo
5/14/1929 - 11/9/2008

 Lillian Mosegard Nicholls
9/27/1918 - 11/3/2008

 Gloria Manriquez Weaver
11/4/1937 - 11/1/2008

 Evan Jae Park
10/27/2008 - 10/27/2008

 RubyNell Hendon
4/1/1918 - 10/28/2008

 Tamotsu Kinoshita
6/5/1921 - 10/29/2008

 Martin Michael Mullins
9/24/1916 - 10/24/2008

 Photos
News
     
Sports
     
Special Events
     
Full Pages
     
 Videos
Solemn honors at Veterans Day ceremonies
Nov 11, 2008
 
Live Oak dominates Westmont
Nov 7, 2008